Drake Maye

Drake Maye led the entire NFL in completion percentage over expected and in adjusted net yards per attempt last season. He finished as the number-two fantasy quarterback. He nearly won MVP. And he's the fourth quarterback off the board. The Muffed 2026 preview on the cleanest quarterback value on this board.

The 2025 season was a sophomore explosion: seventeen games, twenty and a half points a game, QB2 in fantasy, on forty-three ninety-four passing yards, thirty-one touchdowns against just eight interceptions, plus four hundred fifty yards and four scores on the ground. The signature was a five-touchdown, thirty-two point demolition of the Jets in Week 17. But the counting stats undersell it — the efficiency is the story. His completion percentage over expected was the best in the league, plus nine. His adjusted net yards per attempt was the best in the league. He wasn't a volume QB2; he was the most accurate and efficient passer in football.

The arc is a vertical line. As a rookie in 2024 he was a thirteen-and-a-half-point quarterback finding his footing. In year two he jumped to twenty-and-a-half and the QB2 finish. That's not a fluke spike on one number — it's a young quarterback whose underlying accuracy says the leap is real, not borrowed.

Now the part that informs the call honestly. Our quarterback work says the safest fantasy floors belong to rushing quarterbacks, and Maye isn't quite that — about twenty percent of his points came from his legs, useful but short of the elite rushing-floor tier. So we won't pretend he has Lamar's structural floor. What he has instead is the thing that's hardest to fake: accuracy and efficiency that both led the league. That's a skill signal, not luck waiting to regress. The fair caution is simply that a sophomore QB2 finish isn't guaranteed to repeat, and quarterback is a position you can wait on.

The situation, per the reports, only adds to it: New England traded for A.J. Brown, giving Maye a true number-one receiver the offense lacked — and the early chemistry has been the talk of the spring. A league-best-efficiency quarterback adding an alpha receiver entering year three is an ascending asset.

The price: pick sixty-two and a half, the fourth quarterback. Verdict: LEAN — underpriced. He finished QB2 on the best passing efficiency in the league and added an alpha receiver, and he's priced behind three other quarterbacks. The counter, fairly: it's a one-quarterback-league spot you can wait on, and you're partly betting a second-year breakout repeats. But everything under the hood says it should — this is the rare case where the efficiency, not just the points, says the price is too low.

September watch: whether the accuracy holds with a new alpha in the route tree — the CPOE is the whole thesis; and the Brown chemistry, the ceiling-raiser. Your guys, every week. Next preview's queued.